Descriptive metaphysics sets out to describe the actual structure of our thought about the world. This article examines the metaphysics and phenomenology of the self or. The self galen strawson, jesus college, oxford ox1 3dw, uk email. Selfconsciousness, selfascription, and the mental self core. Are you less than enthusiastic for the wonders of technology. An essay in descriptive metaphysics 1959 which discusses strawsons view of person as a primitive concept, in chapter 3. Galen strawson might be described as the montaigne of modern philosophers, endlessly curious, enormously erudite, unafraid of strange, difficult, and provocative propositions, and able to describe them clearlyin other words, he is a true essayist. This chapter first dwells on the background of strawson s metaphysics.
Strawson 1959, 1966, evans 1980, 1982, and cassam 1997, for example, exploring the relation between the capacity for selfconscious. What characteristics distinguish a self from a non self. Strawsons response is to argue that once this view is developed, genuine selfreference emerges as involved in the theorys explanation of the illusion of ownership of experiences. Self and identity researchers have long believed that the self is both a product of situations and a shaper of behavior in situations. Galen strawson, things that bother me kieran setiya. Thirdly, we are interested in the relation of strawsons atomism concerning sesmets and selfexperience and his considerations concerning the. Does the hard sell of todays mass consumerism repel you. Of these, somethe pessimists perhapshold that if the thesis is true, then the concepts of moral obligation and responsibility really have no. How far is strawsons theory of persons a critique of humes theory of self.
Some philosophers say they do not know what the thesis of determinism is. Sep 09, 2011 strawson terms this a kind of sensory experience of its own. Strawson, nagel, and realism abstract by alethea nicole brunson, m. Introduction to logical theory by peter frederick strawson. Strawson hardly stops to ask, impatient to argue that it doesnt. Strawson asserts that true self determination is logically impossible because it requires a. The strawsonian theory of moral responsibility the. Galen john strawson born 1952 is a british analytic philosopher and literary critic who works primarily on philosophy of mind, metaphysics including free will, panpsychism, the mindbody problem, and the self, john locke, david hume, immanuel kant and friedrich nietzsche. Strawsons descriptive metaphysics was the first explicit and elaborate rehabilitation of metaphysics within the analytic tradition. A popular strategy in debates of this sort is to argue that one cannot be said to have some concept c e. In this paper, i provide a framework for accounting for the self, based on a reconstruction of galen strawsons theory of sesmets, or the pearl view, with barry. Feb 14, 2006 strawson, an intellectual prizefighter, soon took on the oxford ordinary language philosopher, jl austin, and the american giant of logic, willard van orman quine. Are you deeply suspicious of globalisation and all that attends it. Pdf the phenomenology and ontology of the self 2000 galen.
Peter strawson said he could make no sense of ideas like free will and determinism. Against narrativity strawson 2004 wiley online library. Reflects on key questions about the existence and nature of the self. The impossibility of moral responsibility galen strawson the basic argument 1. Joseph keim campbell in skepticism and naturalism, p. Self and identity theories assume that people care about themselves. Galen strawson the sense of the self lrb 18 april 1996.
This chapter discusses strawsons contributions to metaphysics with a particular view to his conception of the nature of metaphysicscumontology. A collection of philosophical papers devoted to the subject of the self. Others said that its meaning was too unclear for it to be used in worthwhile philosophical discussion. It will highlight how the theory has been challenged and then argue how the strawsonian theory is underdeveloped and not as coherent as it initially seems. It may be argued that harris, although not a member of the moral community according to watson, has or had the ability to become a member of the moral community but chose not to become one. Mckennas alteration to the strawsonian theory of moral responsibility now allows strawsons theory to respond to the challenge posed by watson. Strawsons descriptive metaphysics oxford scholarship. Galen strawson abstract i argue against two popular claims. Generality constraint to argue that galen strawson.
Others say, or imply, that they do know what it is. A description of the nature of selfexperience leads to a metaphysics of the self, according to which a self is a sesmet, that is, a 1 subject of experience that is a 2 single 3 mental 4 thing. Although we generally deem it essential for a self to be diachronically unified, to. The specification allows i that all things are equally well. This chapter first dwells on the background of strawsons metaphysics. The consciousness deniers by galen strawson the new. John benjamins pp 3954 the phenomenology and ontology of the self 2000 galen strawson.
Although strawson refrains from an explicit theory of persistence, it would be interesting to see which forms of persistence for derek par ts relation r 6 are consistent with his theory of sesmet. In this regard he was one with those englishspeaking philosophers who, following ludwig wittgenstein, thought such questions were pseudoproblems to be dissolved by careful attention to actual language use. In self, mind and body, strawson argues against descartes distinction between mind and body, and in favour of a unitary view of human beings. Descartes 1641 the soul, so far as we can conceive it, is nothing but a system or train of different. He has been a consultant editor at the times literary supplement for. Strawson s descriptive metaphysics its scope and limits. Strawsons freedom and resentment, edited by michael mckenna and paul russell. Strawsons critique of humes bundle theory of the self. Answer by geoffrey klempner i was looking for my old copy of p. Thirdly, we are interested in the relation of strawson s atomism concerning sesmets and self experience and his considerations concerning the.
Nevertheless it cannot solve the main problems of a philosophy of personality or personhood as they are discussed nowadays in philosophy. The undiscovered self do you hate being treated as an object in the organisational systems of bureaucrats and politicians. The self galen strawson, jesus college, oxford ox1 3dw, uk. This paper examines some aspects of strawsons conception of descriptive metaphysics, as it is developed in individuals. Therefore 4 since s is significant, there must in some sense in spme world exist or subsist the king of france.
Jan 09, 2016 in self, mind and body, strawson argues against descartes distinction between mind and body, and in favour of a unitary view of human beings. By the sense of the self i mean the sense that people have of themselves as being, specifically, a mental presence, a mental someone, a conscious subject that has a certain character or personality, and is distinct from all its particular experiences, thoughts, hopes, wishes, feelings and so on. Strawson s freedom and resentment, edited by michael mckenna and paul russell. Occurrences, however, cannot be basic since, standardly they are picked out dependently e. Strawsons theory on moral responsibility outlined in freedom and resentment, focuses on the fact that he associated moral responsibility with. The relevant sense of thing requires careful specification. The self by galen strawson overdrive rakuten overdrive. Strawson, self, mind and body a summary one of the marks of a really great philosopher is to make a really great mistake.
Descriptive metaphysics sets out to describe the actual structure of. Strawsons critique of descartes view of the self date. Strawson then looks at the notion of form and of proof systems. I contend that the basic argument is unpersuasive and unsound. Barry dainton, ingmar persson, marya schechtman, galen strawson, bas van fraassen, and peter van inwagen. I am most grateful to all those who commented on the self. Strawson favours explaining p entails q as p and not q is self contradictory, and explains or elucidates the notion of self contradiction in terms of sentences saying nothing, in effect, they give and then take back simultaneously. An original collection of lauded philosopher galen strawsons writings on the self and consciousness, naturalism and panpsychism. Both diderot and strawson invoke a concept similar to what miri albahari has called, in the context of theravadan buddhism, the twotiered illusion of self, first. One question for this response is whether it is a decisive objection to the noownership theory that an incoherence emerges in its standard explanation as to. But 3 if there in no sense exists a king of france, the sentence is not about anything, and hence not about the king of prance. Benjamin kelsey under the direction of eddy nahmias abstract galen strawsons basic argument is an attempt to prove that no agent can meet the demands for true moral responsibility. Strawson discusses four distinct philosophical topics.
He was the waynflete professor of metaphysical philosophy at the university of oxford magdalen college from 1968 to 1987. According to the basic argument, it makes no difference whether determinism is true or false. This post will discuss strawsons theory of moral responsibility. Strawson s descriptive metaphysics was the first explicit and elaborate rehabilitation of metaphysics within the analytic tradition. Constitutive moral luck and strawsons argument for the. Methodological and theoretical issues in strawsons the self article pdf available in journal of consciousness studies 64. Galen strawson s basic argument is that because self creation is required to be truly morally responsible and self creation is impossible, it is impossible to be truly morally responsible for anything. This chapter discusses strawson s contributions to metaphysics with a particular view to his conception of the nature of metaphysicscumontology.
Strawson holds that if you are to be truly responsible for how you act, you have to be truly responsible for. The second argument sets out to refute the psychological narrativity thesis. Against narrativity galen strawson 1 talk of narrative is. Comprises contributions from leading authorities in the field. Rochefoucauld, put selflove or selfesteem or vanity at the centre of the picture and point. The unity of consciousness, within subjects and between subjects.
Peter frederick strawson stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Galen strawson argues against the narrativity view in favour of his materialist theory of sesmets subjects of experience that are single mental things. The basic argument proceeds on the assumption that, in. By the sense of the self i mean the sense that people have of themselves as being, specifically, a mental presence, a mental someone, a conscious subject that has a certain character or personality, and is distinct from all its particular experiences, thoughts, hopes. In the 1990s many analytic philosophers were inclined to deny that the expression the self referred to anything at all. If this is what makes for selfnarration, why should it belong to a life well lived.
The self galen strawson, jesus college, oxford ox1 3dw. The strawsonian theory of moral responsibility the written word. Aug 18, 2019 strawsons response is to argue that once this view is developed genuine self reference emerges as involved in the theorys explanation of the illusion of ownership of experiences. Galen strawson is presidents chair in philosophy at university of texas at austin. The impossibility of moral responsibility galen strawson. Pdf the substantival phrase the self is very unnatural in most speech. The self ratio special issues galen strawson download. Strawsons concept of person a critical discussion in our paper we want to argue, that strawsons theory may be seen as a conclusive theory of the concept person. Making sense of oneselfwho one is, was, and may become, and therefore the path one should take in the worldis a core self project. Self and identity usc dana and david dornsife college of. Galen strawson the impossibility of moral responsibility received 15 september 1993 i there is an argument, which i will call the basic argument, which appears to prove that we cannot be truly or ultimately morally respon sible for our actions. Selfconsciousness stanford encyclopedia of philosophy.
49 150 1080 283 312 287 631 1002 415 872 1500 656 118 580 274 250 1108 26 12 524 1278 110 417 1190 1058 698 1349 632 566 162 188 987 506 344 91 1399